Forgetting was only the beginning. When seventeen-year-old Sia wakes up on a park bench, she has no idea who or where she is. Yet after a week of being homeless, she’s reunited with her family. At school, she’s powerful and popular. At home, she’s wealthy beyond her dreams. But she quickly realizes her perfect life is a lie. Her family is falling apart and her friends are snobby, cruel and plastic. Worse still, she discovers she was the cruelest one. Mortified by her past, she embarks on a journey of redemption and falls for Kyle, the “geek” she once tormented. Yet all the time she wonders if, when her memories return, she’ll become the bully she was before…and if she’ll lose Kyle. (From Amazon.com)
Sissy: While I enjoyed this book because it is a lovely tale of redemption with a happy ending, and you know I love a happy ending, I have to say I found it to be the slightest bit shallow, and there are some holes in the plot. Sia, in my opinion, doesn’t try hard enough to find out who she is, but rather just dives into the homeless life. When she encounters Kyle in the soup kitchen, she doesn’t ask him about herself, even though he obviously knows her. She solves all her family’s problems a little too neatly, and completely changes herself in the meantime. Not that I don’t like the changes and solutions; I do. I like how everything turns out. I just don’t know if I believe its possible.
Bubby: Oh, Sissy. Sometimes you are such an adult! Yes, it was all too easy to fix Sia’s family and turn around the “mean girls” at the high school – from an adult perspective. But think of it from the viewpoint of a 14 or 15-year-old girl. Especially one who is getting picked on by said mean girls. They are dreaming of a quick fix, some way that people will suddenly wake up and see them for the wonderful people they are and quit tormenting them. In reality, it usually doesn’t happen. It takes lots of time and maturity. That’s why high school reunion revenge fantasies are so popular! When Sia is at the soup kitchen and Kyle calls her out, she is confused and scared. All she knows is that someone is yelling at her and she just wants to get away. It’s obvious to me that trying to get answers would not be her first reaction. The same goes for her family. Everyone with deep family issues wishes that the person with the problem would suddenly wake up and see the light. Josh Grayson just makes those wishes come true.
Sissy: But it’s also true that life doesn’t work that way, and if you have fantasies to that effect you are setting yourself up for repeated disappointment. But, I know that I like my fantasy endings, and it doesn’t make me think that’s the way real life will be. They just allow me some escape, which is perhaps how I should view this book. I also am a fan of goodness, positive changes, and believing that anything is possible, and I guess Josh Grayson tries to incorporate those things in a short 193 pages. I just think this book is too young for my jaded old self in some ways, and I wanted to yell at Sia for being so dumb. Sia is 17, but I suppose the perfect reader of this book might indeed be a 15-year-old. Age 15 is such a distant fly speck on the landscape of my life….my 15 yr old pathos and angst has been relegated to a forgotten and dusty corner of my brain.
Bubby: And that’s a good thing! I really liked the message that having things and money and popularity is not a lasting formula for happiness, and that true joy comes from serving others and loving selflessly. Also, I loved the descriptions of the fabulous clothes, especially the dress Sia wears to the Oscars. My favorite line in the book also comes at the Oscars, when Kyle and Sia get to meet Robert Downy Jr. You’ll have to read the book to find out what happens! Can I just say that if I met Robert Downy Jr. I would probably make a fool of myself – calling him Mr. Iron Man, Sir, or something equally fan-girly. I guess it’s a good thing I am far away from Hollywood!
Sissy: I wouldn’t. I would just say “Hey, Bob.” Sia is the debut novel for Josh Grayson, and I think he did a good job.(rhymes with “Hey, Bob.”) I applaud him for writing a hopeful, happy novel to be placed on the shelves in the midst of more gritty, dark, and lusty offerings, and I hope girls choose this sort of book over those. It just wasn’t the kind of novel that gets to me deeply, like an Amy Harmon or Suzanna Kearsley book. But I say, “Go, fight, write more, Mr. Grayson!” 3 bubbles from me.
Bubby: I am a bit more enthusiastic than you, Sissy. I quite enjoyed Sia. I thought it was a lovely story with a great message and a happy ending for all. 4 bubbles from me.
Click HERE to buy Sia by Josh Grayson at Amazon.com
We received a complimentary copy of Sia in return for a fair review. No other compensations, monetary or otherwise, were given.
© Bubble Bath Books 2013